Thursday, 4 February 2021

Book Review: The Munros by Rab Anderson and Tom Prentice

 
 
The latest edition of the Scottish Mountaineering Club’s The Munros is a wonderful book, arguably the best on the Munros yet. Unlike the first three editions this one is much more than a guidebook – though it does that far better than before. It’s also a great book for browsing and daydreaming.

This is a much bigger book than previous editions. The format is a little larger and there are far more pages – 384 compared with 236 for the first edition and 282 for the third (I don’t have the second one). That means more photographs, including double-page spreads for each section, longer descriptions, and larger maps. The Introduction runs to four pages – previously it was one – and has sections on Sir Hugh Munro and on Munro’s Tables. The latter appear at the end of the book for the first time, along with a list of the Munros by height, and an alphabetical index.  Having the Tables in the book is useful as they give a quick reference to the different sections with relevant OS map numbers, grid references, and page numbers.

One big and welcome change is the inclusion of the subsidiary Tops, both in the route descriptions and in the lists. Maybe more people will now include the Tops in their Munro rounds. They are well worthwhile but have been neglected by most guidebooks, including until now the SMCs. When I was planning my 1996 continuous round of the Munros and Tops the only information was in Irvine Butterfield’s The High Mountains of Britain and Ireland and that was scant. I remember plotting the positions of Tops on OS maps, which didn’t name many of them, from the grid references in Munro’s Tables

The design of The Munros is excellent. It looks really good from the clean lines of the cover – no words on the picture – to the double-page spreads introducing each section and the coloured maps, which have more details than in earlier editions.

The route descriptions are more comprehensive with many options described and are more enjoyable to read just for pleasure than previous ones. Long routes over many Munros are described, not just the one or two standard routes (a half-serious joke about the first edition was the suggestion that to avoid crowds on the hill you should read a route description and then take a different one on the hill).

I’m really enjoying looking through this book, admiring the photos, and reliving walks through the words. I already have more than enough books on the Munros. This one is still a welcome addition to my collection. Credit is due to authors Rab Anderson and Tom Prentice and to the SMC for producing it.

The Munros is published by the Scottish Mountaineering Press and costs £30.

No comments:

Post a comment